IHSH-52 - Ultra Heavy Flannel Western Shirts (Solid)

[riffblaster general]

i love this shirt.  that is all.

[thomasnunnally]

Last 2 years I have passed on the heavy flannel because I have no money, and I always regret it.  I am sure I will this year as well unless I make a change.

[marco]

is there any reason the western version of this shirt gets so much love compared to the IHSH-54? both great shirts but i think the one with side pockets has the edge!

Am i right in thinking that the the western version is cut a little longer than the side pocket version?

[D97x7]

Personally I like both, so I bought both, but if I had to choose one I think it would be the 52. Not sure why really, I suppose I just prefer the snaps over the buttons. Both great shirts though imo.

[marco]

hey thanks for that, how do the two shirts compare fit wise ? just looking at the numbers it looks like the 54 is a little slimmer/neater than the western?

[Giles]

@marco:

is there any reason the western version of this shirt gets so much love compared to the IHSH-54? both great shirts but i think the one with side pockets has the edge!

No idea, I thought the side pocket version would sell quicker…....

[D97x7]

@marco:

hey thanks for that, how do the two shirts compare fit wise ? just looking at the numbers it looks like the 54 is a little slimmer/neater than the western?

Can't really compare I'm afraid, as the 52 is L and the 54 XL, so is obviously larger.

[PETEROCK1]

From marco

is there any reason the western version of this shirt gets so much love compared to the IHSH-54? both great shirts but i think the one with side pockets has the edge!

Am i right in thinking that the the western version is cut a little longer than the side pocket version?

Two words….

snap buttons!

[jacoavlu]

said it many times before, will say it again, please please next year do an ultra heavy flannel western, as usual, snap buttons, and add side pockets

[Giles]

I'm listening this time…...

[J-IV]

@jacoavlu:

said it many times before, will say it again, please please next year do an ultra heavy flannel western, as usual, snap buttons, and add side pockets

YES PLEASE!

[marco]

i must be weird cos i prefer the standard buttons over the snaps.. more in keeping with the rest of the shirt imho. i guess i should put my money were my mouth is and lay down some money eh 

[LandoCal126 0]

@marco:

i must be weird cos i prefer the standard buttons over the snaps.. more in keeping with the rest of the shirt imho. i guess i should put my money were my mouth is and lay down some money eh 

Yup!

[riffblaster general]

i dont think it needs side pockets but please keep making a solid color heavy flannel every year.  this will be a definite purchase for me every year.  i also think i like this better than the normal button version because i already have the IHW01 so I have a wool version of the same shirt already.  Didn't need another.  I have two of the other heavy westerns and I love them.  This is my fav of the 3 that i have.

[Guest]

Riff, how long does the front of your shirt measure? (Shoulder to longest part.)

[riffblaster general]

sorry, just saw this. i'm not at home right now but i'll get that info for you later.

[Jestre]

One of these beautiful black flannels arrived at my doorstep yesterday.  And the first day I had it on my back I had to break up a fight between two girls at work.  I'd say that the flannel was the victor.

[Giles]

Oh, they weren't fighting over you in your shirt?

[Jestre]

Considering that they are teenagers with behavioral issues, I surely hope not

[Giles]