IHSH-455-RED - Slubby Heavy Flannel Check Western Shirt - Red
-
I think a lot of people are going to find that if they take a chance, even though the measurements might look bigger or shorter than what they’re used to, the shirts are still going to fit just as well. Obviously, there will always be outliers, especially for people at the lower end of a size range, where the differences might be more noticeable. But I was pleasantly surprised by how well the 3XL serge fit, even though the chest measurement was considerably larger than what I normally wear.
Looking forward to this on and others just to see how they fit. Of course, I may even buy them.

-
For me, it’s not that I have to buy a different tag size than I’m used to for a particular release. The issue is that the western shirts now have a substantially different silhouette than they have had, at least for the past several years. Sure, it’s a bummer when one particular release doesn’t work out - but that’s the breaks. I think the concern people are voicing is that all the westerns that have been released thus far this year are wider and shorter and boxier than we’ve come to expect. If that’s better for some people and they are happy with that, great. If it is bad for some people and they are disappointed, that’s life. But I don’t think it’s accurate to say that this is a one-off issue for a single release. This looks more like a change in philosophy for how westerns are going to fit, at least this year, and maybe going forward. That’s the implication at least from the post saying they are recalibrating sizing.
-
I haven't bought a western this season, I plan to at least try it to see if I like the fit, it sucks for people like @John-Galt and others, but I'm sure there's been people that had issues with sizing before too... I just hope there's a mix of cuts in future, but who knows. I'd like to try it on my body first before I judge it as it's a little new to me.
-
@northsouthdenimguy can you define "considerably bigger" for me? Thanks

-
I usually shoot for a 25” chest measurement and generally won’t go larger than 25.75”. Anytime I’d see a 26” chest, especially from other brands, I’d steer clear because the rest of the proportions tend to be that much bigger as well. But with the serge it seems like the other measurements run a little smaller proportionally, so it ends up fitting differently than the chest measurement would suggest.
️. -
@samo Agreed.
I don’t see it as complaining vs. more as giving constructive feedback. I’d wager that the IH crew appreciates it.
At the end of the day it’s just people giving their opinions based on past experience.
-
I’m still going to buy one. Just trying to decide whether to size down one or 2 from my normal size. 2 sizes down is around the pit to pit I normally look for.
-
@leathergato said in IHSH-455-RED - Slubby Heavy Flannel Check Western Shirt - Red:
I’m still going to buy one. Just trying to decide whether to size down one or 2 from my normal size. 2 sizes down is around the pit to pit I normally look for.
I’m in the exact same boat. I think I’m going to just size down 1 and trust @northsouthdenimguy that the fit will be on point despite a larger than ideal P2P measurement.
-
Not complaining - just my personal perspective: I’m 5’6” with a runner / athletic build - nothing out of the ordinary. I like my clothes to fit well and I always tuck - it looks best on me imo. I came to rely solely on IH western shirts over the past 5+ years for their slim western shirts that fit my stature so well; the great quality was a bonus. I’m almost always at the bottom of the sizing bell curve with size XS to get that fitted look; occasionally a size small will work and I may have to shrink it to get it near perfect. I have a few work shirts, but they all are too big for the same size XS mainly due to the boxy dimensions and the flared waist and opening. Also, they are typically shorter and difficult to keep tucked when moving around during the day - and I’m only 5’-6”.
Below is the sizing chart for my 399-ORA and for my 397-IND - both purchased in September 2024. These were pretty typical dimensions for westerns and work shirts for the 5+ years I’ve been purchasing IH shirts. Yes - there were always those shirts that strayed from these typical dimensions, but that wasn’t the norm. Also, the size XS westerns may had run a little bigger or smaller within a size of these typical dimensions, but never 2 tag sizes larger with work shirt like waist, opening, and length dimensions. I never wear the 397-ind because it fits poorly and it still has the tags on it. Again - just feedback from my perspective - not complaining. If IH decides to make westerns fit like works, that’s their prerogative. And if that is the direction moving forward (hope not), then I’ll sadly look at other options. Fortunately I have so many western shirts that I can wait this out for quite a while and see what happens, In the meantime my bank account continues to recover from the IH rabbit hole.399-ORA (12oz slubby heavy flannel orange) - purchased 9/24:

397-IND (21oz Sashiko work shirts for indigo) - purchased 9/24:

-
@WithBongInHand It will also help to see some fit pics of the IH crew wearing it and to see what size they wear.
